Breaking News & Independent Reporting

Latest Headlines
U.S

Alabama judge criticizes Aniah’s Law as debate over pretrial detention grows

Jefferson County Circuit Judge David Carpenter called Alabama's Aniah's Law a direct assault on the presumption of innocence, drawing a response from the AG-elect.

Alabama judge criticizes Aniah’s Law as debate over pretrial detention grows
Add DNN Post on GoogleSee more of DNN Post’s journalism by adding us as a preferred source on Google.

Jefferson County Circuit Judge David Carpenter has criticized Alabama’s Aniah’s Law, arguing that expanded powers to hold defendants without bail before trial undermine the presumption of innocence.

“These laws, like Alabama’s Aniah’s Law, are a direct assault on the Constitutional guarantee of the presumption of innocence,” Carpenter wrote in a social media post over the weekend, 1819 News reported. He also questioned why concerns about government surveillance were not matched by similar opposition to pretrial detention.

Alabama Attorney General-elect Katherine Robertson responded in her own post, writing that she “quickly checks notes on the judicial canons of detachment and impartiality,” according to 1819 News.

Advertisement

Aniah’s Law allows judges to deny bail to defendants charged with certain serious crimes. Alabama voters approved an expansion on May 19 adding attempted murder, solicitation or conspiracy to commit murder, and certain weapons offenses involving occupied buildings or vehicles.

Under the law, prosecutors must show at a detention hearing, by clear and convincing evidence, that no release conditions would reasonably ensure a defendant returns to court or protect the public. Defendants have the right to a lawyer, and a judge who denies bail must give written findings or state them on the record.

Carpenter’s past rulings have also drawn scrutiny. 1819 News has reported that he approved a plea agreement that led to the release of Damien McDaniel months before prosecutors say McDaniel carried out a series of killings. McDaniel is presumed innocent, and 1819 News did not report a response from Carpenter on the case.

Carpenter’s comments are criticism of the law, not a ruling. Aniah’s Law remains in effect.

Advertisement

More from U.S